Fraud rarely announces itself. But the warning signs may already be there. Farhan Khan, Senior Director & Head of Forensics at BDO Saudi Arabia, explores five red flags that can signal deeper issues in your organisation and explains how boards and audit committees can strengthen oversight, address vulnerabilities and prevent problems from escalating.
There is a pattern that repeats itself in forensic work. By the time an organisation contacts an independent forensic team, the warning signs have usually been present for months, sometimes years. They appeared in the data, in the controls and in the behaviour of individuals. They may have been visible to people inside the organisation but were not recognised, connected or escalated.
Saudi Arabia's regulatory and governance environment continues to evolve, with increasing expectations around financial integrity, transparency, compliance and accountability. Boards and audit committees therefore need to consider whether their existing assurance mechanisms are sufficient to identify emerging misconduct and control risks before they escalate.
Financial statement audits and forensic reviews serve different purposes. A financial statement audit is designed to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error. A forensic review, by contrast, may focus on specific allegations, transactions, patterns or vulnerabilities, using targeted procedures to examine potential fraud, misconduct or control failures. The nature and extent of the work depend on the engagement's objectives.
The findings that emerge from that question can be uncomfortable. But identifying them early gives organisations an opportunity to respond before the issue escalates.
5 forensic red flags organisations should not ignore
1. Unexplained manual journal entries
The general ledger is one of the most revealing documents in any organisation and one of the least scrutinised outside an investigation. Manual journal entries — entries posted manually rather than through the normal automated posting cycle — are a legitimate and necessary feature of any accounting system. They can also provide a mechanism through which financial results are manipulated or inappropriate adjustments are introduced.
In forensic reviews, certain characteristics warrant closer attention: entries posted outside business hours by senior or privileged system users, with vague or absent supporting references; round-number adjustments that net off across accounts in ways that flatten anomalies visible in automated reporting; and entries that reverse and repost in patterns that are difficult to follow without a data analytics tool.
None of these characteristics is conclusive on its own. Where several indicators occur together, they warrant further examination to establish whether there is a legitimate explanation or evidence of a control failure or misconduct.
Board question: Are we running a regular, analytics-driven review of manual journal entries, and does it focus on the entries that are hardest to explain?
2. Vendor concentration and procurement anomalies
Procurement is inherently susceptible to fraud and misconduct risk, particularly where pricing is judgemental, specifications are difficult to benchmark or transaction volumes make individual transactions difficult to scrutinise. These characteristics create conditions in which control weaknesses, whether deliberate or inadvertent, can persist undetected.
The forensic indicators are well established: a small number of vendors receiving disproportionate shares of contract value, particularly where those vendors were recently registered or have limited verifiable trading history; contracts consistently awarded just below approval thresholds; sole-source justifications that are thin, repetitive or approved by the same individual; and vendors with undisclosed connections to employees, including common addresses, bank account details or beneficial ownership links.
What is striking in practice is not necessarily the sophistication of these arrangements, but how long they can persist before discovery. The data that would have revealed them was available throughout. Periodic vendor risk analytics, applying known fraud indicators across the active vendor population, can help organisations identify these patterns before they become entrenched.
Board question: When did we last run a structured analytics review of our active vendor population against known fraud indicators, and did it cover beneficial ownership?
3. Misalignment between revenue and cash collections
This red flag is particularly relevant to organisations with significant credit sales, high transaction volumes or complex customer account activity. When movements in recognised revenue are not consistent with the pattern of cash collections, the difference warrants explanation.
In real estate development, for example, a growing gap between recognised revenue and collections can warrant closer examination, particularly where instalment-based sales are made without sufficiently robust assessment of customers' ability to meet future payment obligations. Over time, significant receivable balances may accumulate while reported revenue continues to reflect strong commercial activity. The resulting divergence may indicate underlying credit or recoverability concerns, but it can also be a warning sign of aggressive revenue recognition or other practices intended to present stronger underlying sales performance.
Sometimes the explanation is straightforward: timing differences, credit terms or a legitimate change in business mix. Sometimes it is not. Unexplained gaps can point to overstated revenue, manipulated collection records, misappropriated payments, unusual credits, suppressed customer accounts or other customer-account anomalies. Each of these is a forensic and financial control issue that warrants investigation on its own terms.
Board question: Can management readily explain why revenue and cash conversion are moving differently?
If that question produces hesitation, vagueness or an inability to produce reconciled data quickly, that itself is informative. An independent review of the revenue-to-cash cycle, combining transaction analytics with testing of revenue recognition, receivable ageing and subsequent collections, together with a sample review of credits, write-offs and customer account activity, can identify anomalies that routine financial review processes are not designed to surface.
4. Governance that exists on paper but not in practice
This can be one of the most difficult red flags to identify through conventional financial review alone. An organisation can have a carefully drafted anti-fraud policy, a whistleblowing mechanism, a conflict-of-interest register and a delegation of authority matrix, and none of them may be operating as designed.
In forensic reviews, it is common to find policies that have not been updated to reflect changes in the business; committees that meet on paper but do not meaningfully challenge management; approval authorities that are routinely bypassed without consequence; and whistleblowing channels that employees either do not know exist or do not trust.
The governance framework is present. The governance is not. This matters for two reasons. First, any assessment of an organisation's response to a misconduct event will look closely at whether the governance framework was genuinely operational, not just whether the documents existed. Second, governance that exists only on paper provides no actual protection against the risks it was designed to address.
Board question: Is there independent evidence that our governance frameworks are being followed, or are we relying on the fact that the documents exist?
5. Unusual activity around financial reporting deadlines
The periods immediately before quarter-end and year-end closings can represent heightened-risk periods in an organisation's financial reporting cycle. The pressure to meet financial targets, satisfy covenant requirements or present a particular picture to investors, counterparties or other stakeholders creates an environment in which control exceptions are more likely to be overlooked and individuals more likely to act outside their normal parameters.
In forensic work, this can manifest in several ways: revenue recognised in periods that may not appropriately reflect the underlying performance obligations; provisions reversed in the days before a reporting date without adequate justification; intercompany transactions that manage reported positions across entities; and unusual activity in cash and receivables accounts in the final days of a period.
The data footprint of these activities is usually visible. The question is whether anyone is looking at the right data, at the right time, with the right frame of reference. A targeted forensic review of period-end journals and adjustments can provide a different level of scrutiny from routine financial review processes, particularly where it combines transaction analytics with supporting-document review.
Board question: Does our internal audit or audit committee review include a targeted analysis of period-end adjustments, and is that review independent of the finance function?
When red flags become regulatory concerns
The five red flags above share a common characteristic: each of them, when identified early, provides an opportunity for investigation and corrective action. When they surface through external scrutiny rather than internal processes, the consequences are considerably more significant.
Certain matters can carry heightened regulatory significance, including weaknesses in AML and CFT controls, misconduct involving public funds, financial reporting irregularities in regulated entities and deficiencies in record-keeping or regulatory cooperation.
“The likelihood of escalation increases where warning signs are repeated, involve senior management, indicate deliberate concealment, affect regulated activities or are not appropriately investigated and remediated once identified,” says Farhan Khan, Senior Director & Head of Forensics at BDO Saudi Arabia.
While the underlying misconduct is important, regulatory scrutiny may also extend to whether the organisation had an effective control environment capable of preventing, detecting and responding to it. As governance and compliance expectations in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia continue to develop, the adequacy of that control environment becomes increasingly relevant.
What boards and audit committees can do
Three practical measures can significantly strengthen an organisation's ability to identify these risks early.
The first is a targeted forensic risk assessment: a structured, time-bound review applying forensic methodology to the highest-risk areas of the organisation. Not an investigation, not an audit, but an independent assessment designed to answer one question: where are we most vulnerable and what does the evidence show?
The second is data analytics as a standing control. The ability to interrogate journal entries, vendor transactions, payroll anomalies and cash movements on a regular basis — quarterly or even monthly rather than annually — can significantly enhance the organisation's ability to identify anomalies before they become patterns.
The third is making the whistleblowing mechanism genuinely functional. A trusted reporting channel that protects confidentiality, permits anonymous reporting where appropriate, safeguards against retaliation and supports impartial, timely investigation can be an important source of early warning.
Where such mechanisms operate effectively, concerns can surface earlier, giving organisations greater opportunity to respond before they escalate. Where concerns are not surfaced internally, they may instead emerge through regulatory scrutiny, litigation, external reporting or other channels.
Find the risks before they escalate
Organisations that apply a forensic lens before a significant issue emerges are better positioned to identify vulnerabilities early and respond before they escalate. Saudi Arabia's regulatory and governance landscape continues to become more demanding.
The question for boards and audit committees is whether they have the visibility, controls and escalation mechanisms needed to identify warning signs early and respond effectively.
How BDO Saudi Arabia can help
If your organisation is looking to assess its exposure to fraud, misconduct or control weaknesses before they escalate, BDO Saudi Arabia's Forensics team can support with targeted forensic risk assessments, data analytics, control reviews and independent investigations.

